Japonesque Make Up Cases

I really need a makeup bag - in fact, my mother did:)
It is really nice, black compact organizer makeup mirror with a flop-up, but the zipper is down, which deal with this thing every morning a hassle for her: \
So I wanted to buy him a new one, but this particular genre has been abandoned.

I found this:
http://foreverfemale.com/shop/product_in ...

and

http://foreverfemale.com/shop/product_in ...

or

http://www.amazon.com/Japonesque-Travel- ...

Which should I do? She really wants a bag with a mirror, but perhaps the second is better ...? idk
help me D:

I like second best. It seems more functional.
However, you know that your mother BESST then you play:)